Are We Setting Kids Up for Failure by Ensuring Equity in Education for Same Outcomes for Students in School?
We’ve all heard the term “equity” in education, but what does it really mean for kids? And more importantly, how does teaching equity, especially the kind that focuses on achieving the same outcomes for all students—set them up for adulthood, where the rules are very different? Once students graduate, the world doesn’t guarantee the same outcomes, but rather expects them to apply themselves and to find the ways and resources they need to achieve the outcomes they want. So, is it fair to teach one way throughout childhood and then switch to a whole different game plan when they reach adulthood to pursue success and achieving their dreams?
How do we ensure the definition of equity in education aligns with real-world expectations, and are we risking students' success by not clarifying the difference?
I'm sure we can all see the value in ensuring that all students have the resources they need to thrive and reach their full potential. Students have different learning styles, excel in various skills, and naturally struggle in others. But this raises a fundamental question:
"is it more important to push for every student to reach the same skill level through equitable outcomes, or should we focus on nurturing the individual strengths and passions that allow students to shine?"
If we emphasize building on their natural skills and interests, does that set them up for a more fulfilling and successful life? Or does constantly focusing on areas where they struggle, aiming to reach proficiency in all subjects, risk leaving students feeling frustrated, always battling their weaknesses rather than excelling in their strengths?
What's the Difference between Equity of Outcome and Equity of Opportunity?
To make sense of this, let’s break it down. In schools, equity of outcome means that all students, no matter their background, effort or skill level, should achieve similar results. This approach helps level the playing field, giving disadvantaged students extra support to reach the same goals as their peers, which is important early on in education. But unfortunately, life outside of school doesn’t always work this way. As adults, we’re expected to create our own success based on our efforts, skills, and drive. Equity of opportunity, on the other hand, means everyone gets access to the same resources and chances, but how far they go depends on what they do with those opportunities.
The Disconnect of Expectations?
Focusing on ensuring that every student reaches a "proficient" level in every skill, it raises an important question:
"Should we instead shift toward helping students excel in areas aligned with their natural interests and strengths?"
This approach could better prepare them for adulthood by teaching them how their individual talents contribute to a diverse society, where every skill plays a role in the larger puzzle of a thriving community.
When students are expected to achieve proficiency in every subject, often with additional support just to match their peers' outcomes - how does that affect their self-confidence and focus? While this might offer short-term benefits, it poses challenges once these supports disappear after graduation. This transition can lead to frustration and a sense of unpreparedness as they navigate adulthood, where success is largely determined by effort, personal initiative, and applying their unique talents with their passions. Without these tools to independently thrive, they may struggle to find their footing.
In contrast, emphasizing each student’s strengths and passions could build their confidence and better equip them for real-world success.
By allowing students to focus on what they naturally excel at, students would be more likely to lead fulfilling, successful lives, utilizing their abilities in ways that contribute meaningfully to society.
So, How Can We Best Prepare Kids for the Real World?
It doesn’t have to be one or the other. Schools can combine both approaches to give students the tools they need to succeed in adulthood while still addressing the very real challenges some students face. Here’s how:
Teach Effort and Responsibility Early:
Even while providing extra support, schools should encourage students to take charge of their own learning and understand the resources that can help them along the way. It's not just about fostering independence but also teaching students to identify what kind of support they need—whether it's extra practice, guidance from a teacher, or tools that help them study better. By learning to recognize and seek out the right resources, students can become more self-reliant and proactive in their education. Yes, assistance is important, but students need to grasp that this support won't always be there. Over time, they must learn to not only rely on their own efforts but also understand how to access and use resources like study tools, mentors, or feedback to help themselves succeed. This combination of self-awareness and resourcefulness will prepare them to handle future challenges independently.
The Growth Mindset and Failing Forward Approach:
Teaching students about a growth mindset—where they learn that their abilities can grow with effort—helps shift the focus from fixed abilities (where they think, "I'm either good at this or I'm not") to seeing challenges as opportunities for growth. A key part of this is teaching students that it's okay to fail. Failure isn’t the end—it’s a stepping stone to success. By framing failure as a part of the learning process, we encourage students to experiment, take risks, and find out what their true strengths and passions are, without fear of punishment or shame in areas where they struggle.
All that truly matters is their effort and persistence. When students understand that hard work and resilience are more important than getting everything right the first time, they can approach learning with a more positive, open mindset. This teaches them that their worth isn’t tied to perfection but to how they face and overcome obstacles. Helping students learn to embrace failure as a learning tool prepares them not only for school but for life, where setbacks are inevitable and growth comes from how they respond to those setbacks.
A Gradual Transition to Independence:
It’s not realistic to remove all support at once. Schools can phase out extra help gradually, encouraging students to take more responsibility as they get older. For example, high school students might receive less hand-holding than elementary and middle school students, which helps make the transition to college or the workforce smoother. As students progress through high school, they should begin to narrow their focus on the areas and skills where they are most proficient and naturally interested.
By honing in on these strengths, students not only build practical expertise but also develop a deeper sense of confidence and self-awareness. When students understand what they excel at, it empowers them to pursue those areas with greater intensity, leading to better results and more fulfilling career paths. This gradual process of focusing on their interests also helps them see how their unique strengths can contribute to their long-term success, allowing them to enter adulthood with a clear sense of direction and purpose. Encouraging students to identify and excel in these areas is essential for fostering both independence and self-assurance, giving them the foundation to thrive in the real world.
Life Skills Are Key:
Beyond academic knowledge, schools must prioritize teaching practical life skills like social-emotional learning, time management, problem-solving, and self-discipline. These skills are crucial for adulthood, helping students realize that their future success depends on how they apply themselves, regardless of external support. By mastering these skills, students can achieve their personal definitions of success and contribute meaningfully to society as well-rounded, effective individuals. Equipping students with these tools ensures they can navigate the complexities of life with confidence and purpose.
Fairness in Adulthood
As students grow, it’s crucial they learn the difference between fairness in school and fairness in life. In the real world, fairness often means access to opportunities, but not guaranteed results. Students need to understand that once they leave school, success is no longer about receiving equal outcomes, but about using the opportunities they’ve been given to the best of their ability.
So, are we setting kids up for failure by teaching equity in school? Not if we balance it right. By blending support with accountability, we can help students build the resilience, independence, and life skills they’ll need to thrive as adults. The goal is to ensure that when they step out into the world, they’re not only ready for the opportunities ahead but also prepared to create their own success.
Comments